To main content

Technology trajectories: are we making progress on sustainability?

Abstract

This research examines how qualitative assessment methods can be developed to bridge with quantitative approaches for evaluating the systemic Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) impacts of emerging technologies at scale. As governments and industries increasingly turn to emerging technologies to advance the green transition, understanding their broader implications for sustainable development becomes essential. Existing research on technology and the SDGs either stays at the policy level or narrows in on a technology's primary function, and the qualitative and quantitative tools available each capture only part of the picture, leaving a technology's wider, systemic SDG impacts largely unaddressed. The overarching research question (RQ) this thesis seeks to address is: “How can qualitative assessment methods help bridge quantitative approaches for evaluating the systemic SDG impacts of emerging technologies at scale?” To address this, a qualitative SDG interlinkage assessment methodology and a framework for integrating it with quantitative approaches (Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) and Multi Regional Input Output (MRIO) analysis) is developed, illustrated and refined through application to different emerging technologies in different development stages: point-of-care microfluidics, offshore wind and solar photovoltaics. The thesis consists of four papers, which together help address the overarching RQ. Paper 1 presents a proof-of-concept qualitative SDG interlinkage assessment methodology, applied to microfluidics technology and linked to the Responsible Innovation framework. It develops a three-phase approach to identify which SDG targets are relevant to a given technology and analyze interlinkages qualitatively. Connecting this to the Responsible Innovation framework means it operationalizes the reflexivity, anticipation, inclusion and responsiveness of the framework. Paper 2 extends this qualitative methodology to offshore wind: a technology central to the energy transition, with a longer and more complex value chain than the proof- of-concept case, and comprising two sub-technologies at different stages of maturity (fixed- and floating bottom). It combines the qualitative interlinkages approach with quantitative MRIO assessment, incorporating quantitative scenarios to assess the SDG impacts at scale. The paper finds offshore wind's sustainability impacts extend beyond the installation site to material-extraction regions, generating both economic benefits and overlooked environmental costs. Floating designs reduce seabed disturbance, but their higher steel intensity limits overall sustainability, with circularity being a critical gap. Paper 3 builds on the methodological insights from Papers 1 and 2 to develop a hybrid five-phase framework for assessing the systemic SDG impacts of emerging technologies in a structured manner. This framework formalizes how qualitative and quantitative methods (interlinkage assessment, LCA, and MRIO) can be integrated and used within the SDG framework depending on a specific technology context. Paper 4 extends this framework to tandem perovskite solar photovoltaics, a less mature technology, by incorporating qualitative scenario development combined with MRIO modelling. The paper examines how different production location and technology scenarios for solar PV manufacturing in Europe affect sustainability outcomes by 2040. It shows that European localization boosts economic and social outcomes, while environmental performance depends on the carbon intensity of the energy mix used in production. This is further complicated by uncertain module lifetimes and continued dependence on Chinese-dominated silicon supply chains. Drawing on the findings from all four papers, the thesis answers the overarching RQ by proposing a methodology in which qualitative SDG interlinkage assessment structures which impacts are assessed and how, while quantitative LCA and MRIO generates specific, technology-dependent results. This thesis distinguishes interlinkages at the technology, industry, and systemic level, showing that these emerge at different points as a technology diffuses, requiring different assessment methods. This not only supports a more systemic understanding of how emerging technologies shape progress toward the SDGs, but also offers a transferable approach for assessing other emerging technologies throughout their diffusion pathway.

Category

Doctoral thesis

Language

English

Author(s)

Affiliation

  • SINTEF Industry / Sustainable Energy Technology
  • Norwegian University of Science and Technology

Year

2026

Publisher

Norwegian University of Science and Technology

ISBN

9788235305664

View this publication at Norwegian Research Information Repository