To main content

We need to accelerate the energy transition

Nils Røkke moderating the panel discussion on the energy transition at the SDG Pavilion during COP31 in Antalya. (Nils Røkke, SINTEF, Miguel Muñoz Rodríguez, Iberdrola, Petya Icheva, IRENA, Miquel Muñoz Cabré, Stockholm Environment Institute, , og Ricardo Marroquín Paiz, ICC Guatemala.)
The technologies exist and ambitions are high. Yet the energy transition is moving too slowly. At COP31, Nils Røkke moderated an international panel on what is standing in the way of faster implementation.

The panel discussion took place at the SDG Pavilion, hosted by UN DESA and the Sustainable Water & Energy Solutions Network. Focusing on the path from climate targets to implementation, the panel brought together participants from Europa, USA and Guatemala.

The starting point was the need to accelerate the transition significantly. More sectors need to be electrified, more renewable energy needs to be deployed, and alternatives are needed for those areas that cannot be directly electrified.

But the discussion quickly moved to a more difficult question: How can we accelerate the transition without creating new bottlenecks that ultimately slow it down?

“Dress me slowly, because I’m in a hurry”

Petya Icheva from IRENA pointed out that many of the targets and ambitions are already in place. The challenge is to deploy solutions at scale. International ambitions must be translated into national enabling frameworks, and there is no single approach that works everywhere.

Miquel Muñoz Cabré from the Stockholm Environment Institute captured the paradox with a Spanish saying:

“Dress me slowly, because I’m in a hurry.”

The message was not that the transition should move more slowly. Quite the opposite. But projects that are rushed without sufficient planning and engagement risk delays and higher costs. In practice, the push for speed can end up slowing the deployment of new solutions.

Cabré highlighted the expansion of solar and wind power in Africa. The markets are growing rapidly, but demand is growing even faster. At the same time, solar capacity is being built without being connected to the grid. More renewable generation will have limited impact if the infrastructure around it fails to keep pace.

There is no “one size fits all”

Differences between countries became particularly clear when the discussion turned to hydropower.

In Norway, hydropower is an important source of flexibility in the energy system. In Guatemala, hydropower accounts for a significant share of renewable electricity generation, but drought and El Niño also make dependence on water a source of vulnerability.

Ricardo Marroquín Paiz from ICC Guatemala therefore described the need for a more diversified energy mix and the importance of learning from solutions already implemented elsewhere.

“We can replicate measures that others have tested, but we need to adapt them to our own system if they are to have an impact,” he said.

The same point came up repeatedly during the discussion: Technologies and experience can be shared, but the energy transition does not take place under the same conditions everywhere.

Which trade-offs are we not talking enough about?

Røkke challenged the panel to consider which trade-offs we are not honest enough about when discussing the need to accelerate the transition. This shifted the discussion from technology choices to costs, distribution and public acceptance.

Who pays when a solution is good for the climate but more expensive for consumers? How are people and local communities affected by new energy infrastructure? And how do we ensure that the energy transition actually improves access to energy rather than simply creating a lower-carbon energy system?

Icheva highlighted fairness and public acceptance as key to a successful energy transition. Examples from Guatemala showed how regulatory frameworks and taxes can also make renewable alternatives less attractive than fossil-based solutions.

The energy transition is also a resource transition

Towards the end, Røkke turned the discussion to the resources required for the energy transition itself.

Solar panels, wind turbines, batteries and power grids all require materials. Renewable energy installations also have finite lifetimes and will eventually need to be decommissioned. Rodríguez therefore stressed that the energy transition and the shift towards a more circular economy cannot be treated as two separate challenges.

The panel discussion showed why moving from ambition to implementation is more complex than simply.

Contact person