That was the common thread when SINTEF and NTNU gathered policymakers, funders, industry and researchers at COP31 in Antalya for the side event "From Technology Transfer to Technology Partnership: Powering the Energy Transition".
"Technology was not transferred. It was developed in partnership." That is how Rajendra Shende, who led UNEP's OzonAction programme for nearly two decades, summed up the one global environmental effort that fully succeeded: saving the ozone layer. So why, he asked, hasn't the same happened for climate and energy? "That is why we are meeting for the 31st time at a COP."
"We love technology – but that is rarely the problem"
"We love technology at SINTEF," Anneli Alatalo Paulsen, Head of New Global Markets at SINTEF, admitted as she opened the session. But the problem is seldom that the technology is missing. The barriers are logistics, systems, culture and communication. That is why SINTEF increasingly looks for partners beyond the usual ones – governments, finance, local industry and civil society – along entire value chains.
She gave two examples. In Zambia, critical minerals are mined in large volumes, but the value and the processing leave the country. The Critical Minerals Partnership is setting up a blended-finance fund, with Norad among the backers, to secure processing within Zambia. SINTEF's role is to make sure best available technology is used, that ethical standards hold and that women's voices are heard. "There is a set of values around this project, not only economics."
The second, OPTOCE, works with cement plants in eight Asian countries, using non-recyclable plastic to replace coal. The 20 pilots have the potential to keep around one million tonnes of plastic out of the ocean every year.
SINTEF wants to do far more of this kind of work, Paulsen said. What is missing are the mechanisms: Horizon Europe offers some, but researchers need more ways to work with partners in the Global South on equal terms.
Partnerships that create jobs
Zambia's Minister of Green Economy and Environment, Gilbert Siame, has spent time teaching at NTNU, and being in the room, he said, felt like coming home. "My journey would not be complete without the Norwegian experience. It has shaped me."
With a median age of 19, the pressure to create jobs in Zambia is enormous, and green industrialisation is a top priority. Partnerships like the one with SINTEF and NTNU deliver not only research and technology, but jobs. Finance matters, Siame said, but mobilisation matters even more: when interests meet across borders, it creates opportunities for Norwegian actors too. "That ecosystem is what it looks like when you have a system that delivers."
What Zambia wants is skills and technology that answer to local needs: Which batteries do we actually need locally? What capacity is required? What has to be modified? Answering that requires co-creation – with industry, but also with local communities. Partnerships must be partnerships between people, Siame said. That is what builds trust, "on terms that are predictable, mutual, respectful and beneficial". "This is what success should look like."
From technology readiness to ecosystem readiness
Moderator Professor Peter Gotsch, representative of NTNU's Global South Initiative, reminded the panel that North–South is only one kind of partnership – the North has a lot to learn from the Global South as well. And cooperation is not always voluntary: "We have to do it whether we like it or not." Shende proposed a concrete next step: a round table with the partners on technology transformation, with young people at the table.
Diana Casey, Director for Cement and ESG at the Global Cement and Concrete Association, took the industry view. A pilot proves that something works; scaling it is another matter. "We have to move beyond technology readiness – we need ecosystem readiness." Can people operate it? Is the infrastructure there? Can it be financed? Are there customers? "Technology transfer is not copy and paste." A successful partnership, she said, should leave capability behind.
Mari Sundli Tveit, CEO of the Research Council of Norway and President of Science Europe, brought the funder's perspective: long-term, predictable funding, designed so that equitable partnerships can actually happen. "We can do much better," she admitted. Building real reciprocity takes time, and the practical question is how to frame calls so that time is paid for. Research funders are now meeting partners in Africa to take this forward. "We're starting from a good place. But there is a lot to do."
Design the partnership in from day one
Paulsen closed with the lesson of the day: design partnerships and local anchoring in from the start, not at the end. The question to ask on day one is simple: who needs to be on board for this to scale? Get them in early.
The event builds on the eight recommendations NTNU and SINTEF have brought to COP31 in the report From ambition to implementation, which calls for equal partnerships with countries in the Global South, local value creation, and research and higher education as an integrated part of delivering the Paris Agreement.
Speakers: Anneli Alatalo Paulsen, SINTEF · Professor Peter Gotsch, NTNU's Global South Initiative (moderator) · Mari Sundli Tveit, Research Council of Norway · Gilbert Siame, Minister, Zambia · Rajendra Shende, former UNEP, Green TERRE Foundation · Diana Casey, GCCA